Skip to main content
Atlantis Prime logo top - HomepageAtlantis Prime logo scroll - Homepage
  • (212)-258-0756
  • info@atlantisprimerestaurant.com
  • Menu
  • Drinks
  • Specials
  • Events
  • Reserve
  • Private Events
  • Jobs
  • Facebook page
  • Instagram page
  • Google page
Atlantis Prime logo top - HomepageAtlantis Prime logo scroll - Homepage
  • Facebook page
  • Instagram page
  • Google page
  • Menu
  • Drinks
  • Specials
  • Events
  • Reserve
  • Private Events
  • Jobs

Our Menu

  • Menu
  • Lunch Prix Fixe
  • Pre-Theatre Menu
  • Dessert Menu
  • Thanksgiving Menu

Please inform management of any allergies you or your guest may have.
Consuming raw or undercooked food may increase your risk of foodborne illness.

Crudo

Blue Point Oysters*
$3.50/each

Blue Point oysters, mignonette, cocktail sauce, oyster crackers.

Little Neck Clams
$2.50/each

Fresh littleneck clams, mignonette, cocktail sauce, oyster crackers.

Albacore Tuna Tartare*
$29.50

Avocado, shallot, jalapeño, sesame, seaweed salad, ginger-soy ponzu, taro crisps.

Cured Salmon Tartare*
$29.50

Cured salmon, avocado, radish, salmon roe, lemon ponzu, taro crisps.

Appetizer

Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail
$6.50/each

Chilled jumbo shrimp, house cocktail sauce, fresh lemon.

Buffalo Mozzarella
$20.50

Buffalo mozzarella, vine-ripened tomato, red onion, fresh basil, garlic vinaigrette.

Maine Lobster Ceviche
$32.50

Maine lobster, tomato, red onion, jalapeño, cilantro, fresh citrus vinaigrette.

Burata Con Pana
$22.50

Creamy burrata, roasted tomato, pineapple, pickled garlic bread, basil-infused olive oil.

Clams Oreganata
$19.50

Littleneck clams, seasoned panko, fresh herbs, white wine, lemon.

Beef Meatballs
$19.50

House-made beef meatballs, marinara, melted mozzarella, fresh basil.

Spanish Octopus
$31.50

Grilled Spanish octopus, seasonal vegetables, creamy mustard sauce.

Fried Calamari
$23.50

Crispy panko-crusted calamari, house marinara.

Sushi & Sashimi

Atlantis Roll
$24.50

Shrimp tempura, avocado, eel sauce.

Cured Salmon Roll*
$22.50

Cured salmon, cucumber, cream cheese, salmon roe, eel sauce.

Spicy Tuna Roll*
$22.50

Tuna belly, cucumber, crispy panko, spicy mayo.

California Roll
$25.50

Crab meat, avocado, cucumber, sesame, spicy ponzu.

Akami Tuna Sashimi*
$25.50

Akami tuna, sesame, chives, pickled ginger, honey ponzu.

Japanese A5 Wagyu Tataki*
$85.50

4 oz Japanese A5 Wagyu, lightly seared, sea salt flakes, truffle ponzu.

Soup

Lobster Bisque
$20.50

Maine lobster, brandy, cream.

French Onion
$17.50

Caramelized onions, toasted bread, melted mozzarella.

Soup of The Day
$14.50

Chef's daily preparation.

Salad

Little Gem Caesar
$17.50

Little Gem lettuce, croutons, house Caesar dressing.

Summer Arugula Salad
$19.50

Arugula, mango, strawberries, blueberries, grapes, sliced almonds, blue cheese, lemon vinaigrette.

Chopped Green Salad
$16.50

Mesclun, arugula, cucumber, tomato, roasted peppers, red onion, peas, corn, Parmesan, lemon vinaigrette.

Seafood Salad
$28.50

Shrimp, calamari, octopus, tomato, roasted peppers, red onion, house vinaigrette.

Steak & Chops

Filet Mignon
$70.50

12 oz center-cut filet mignon, au poivre saucе.

Dry-Aged Bone-In Ribeye
$80.50

28 oz, dry-aged in house.

Dry-Aged Bone-In New York Strip
$68.50

22 oz, dry-aged in house.

Porterhouse for Two
$135.50

40 oz porterhouse, dry-aged in house.

Rack of Lamb
$58.50

16 oz double cut, crusted with mustard and panko.

Chateaubriand for Two
$125.50

22 oz Certified Angus Beef tenderloin, au poivre sauce.

Japanese A5 Wagyu Tenderloin
$180.00

8 oz Japanese A5 Wagyu tenderloin, au poivre sauce .

Japanese A5 Wagyu Strip
$250.00

12 oz Japanese A5 Wagyu strip, intensely marbled with exceptional richness and umami.

Entrée

Surf & Turf
$80.50

8 oz petitfilet mignon, 7 oz lobster tail, drawn butter, au poivre sauce.

Sesame Akami Tuna Tataki*
$58.50

Seared akami tuna, sesame, ponzu, eel saucе, mango-radish salad, lemon vinaigrette.

Whole Grilled Branzino
$40.50

Mediterranean sea bass, grilled whole.

Pan-Seared Halibut
$46.50

Center-cut halibut, lemon-caper piccata sauce.

Faroe Island Salmon
$39.50

Grilled Faroe Island salmon, Dijon mustard sauce.

Shrimp Scampi
$38.50

Jumbo shrimp, garlic, shallots, cherry tomatoes, served over creamy risotto.

Twin Lobster Tail
$65.50

Two 7 oz lobster tails, garlic, fresh lemon, drawn butter.

Lobster Ravioli
$39.50

House-made lobster ravioli, spinach, shallots, creamy brandy sauce.

Seafood Risotto
$42.50

Arborio rice, garlic, mixed seafood, white wine, fresh herbs.

Sides

Mashed Potato
$14.50
Lyonnaise Potato
$16.50
Steak Fries
$14.50
Sautéed Mushroom & Onions
$16.50
Mac & Cheese
$19.50
Broccoli
$15.50
Asparagus
$17.50
Creamed Spinach
$16.50
Sauteed Spinach
$15.50
Shishito Peppers
$17.50

Available 11:30 am 3:30 pm
$30.00 Per Person

Appetizer

(Choice of One)

Fried Calamari

Golden squid, panko, marinara sauce.

Meatballs

Beef meatballs, marinara, melted mozzarella, fresh basil.

Little Gem Caesar

Little gem lettuce, croutons, fresh Caesar dressing.

Soup of The Day

Chef's specialty for the day.

Entrée

(Choice of One)

Salmon

Grilled Faroe Islands salmon.

Petit Filet Mignon (+$15.00)

Au poivre sauce.

Chicken Parmigiana

Bell & Evans breast, panko, parmesan cheese, marinara sauce.

Chicken Fiorentina

Bell & Evans chicken breast, topped with spinach and mozzarella, finished with white wine butter sauce.

Mushroom Ravioli

Homemade ravioli, shallots, creamy truffle sauce.

Spaghetti Meatballs

Homemade spaghetti, beef meatballs, marinara sauce.

Rigatoni Vodka Sauce

Homemade rigatoni pasta, sautéed in a pink vodka sauce.

Side

(Choice of One)

Sautéed Broccoli
Creamed Spinach
Mashed Potatoes

Available 4 pm - 8 pm
$55.00 Per Person

Appetizer

(Choice of One)

Fried Calamari

Golden squid, panko, marinara sauce.

Meatballs

Beef meatballs, marinara, melted mozzarella, fresh basil.

Little Gem Caesar

Little gem lettuce, croutons, fresh Caesar dressing.

Burrata Con Panna

Roasted tomato, pineapple, garlic bread, basil-infused olive oil.

Soup of The Day

Chef's specialty for the day.

Entrée

(Choice of One)

Salmon

Grilled Faroe Islands salmon.

Branzino

Grilled whole Mediterranean bass.

NY Strip Steak (+$15.00)

Boneless, dry-aged in-house.

Chicken Parmigiana

Bell & Evans breast, panko, parmesan cheese, marinara sauce.

Chicken Française

Bell & Evans breast, egg, white wine sauce.

Lobster Ravioli

Homemade ravioli, shallots, spinach, creamy brandy sauce.

Rigatoni Bolognese

Homemade rigatoni pasta, beef meat sauce, fresh basil leaf.

Side

(Choice of One)

Broccoli Sautéed
Creamed Spinach
Mashed Potatoes

Bottle of Wine

Manager Selection Bottle of Wine
$50.00

Dessert

Raspberry Cheesecake
$15.95
Napoleon Cake
$16.95
Vesuvius Cake
$15.95
Blackout Cake
$15.95
Amaretto Cream
$16.95
Crème Brulee
$15.95
NY Apple Crumb
$15.95

Served warm. Add ice cream $4.00

Ice Cream
$12.95

Available flavors.

Sorbet
$12.95

Available flavors.

Cordials

Amaro
$13.95
Bailey’s
$13.95
B & B
$14.95
Disarono Amaretto
$15.95
Frangelico
$14.95
Grand Marnier
$14.95
Sambuca Romana
$13.95

Dessert Wine

Lamoreaux Landing
$13.95

Vidal Ice

Wagner
$15.95

Vidal Ice

Inniskillin Ice
$27.95

Vidal Oak Aged

La Chartreuse
$14.95

Sauternes

Petit Guiraud
$16.95

Sauternes

Chateau Rieussec
$21.95

Sauternes

Ports

Sandeman Port
$13.95

Fine Ruby

Fonseca Port
$13.95

Bin #27

Taylor Fladgate
$15.95

10 Year Old

Taylor Fladgate
$20.95

20 Year Old

Graham’s Port
$18.95

10 Year Old

Graham’s Port
$21.95

20 Year Old

$125.00 Per Person, excluding Tax and Gratuity

Appetizer

(Choice of One)

Seafood Tower

Jumbo shrimp, oysters, little neck clams.

Shrimp Romano

Jumbo shrimp, gorgonzola cheese, jalapeno, garlic bread.

Fried Calamari

Golden squid, panko, marinara sauce.

Little Gem Caesar

Little gem lettuce, croutons, fresh Caesar dressing.

Burrata Con Pana

Roasted tomato, pineapple, garlic bread, basil infused olive oil.

Pumpkin Soup

Chef's specialty for the day.

Second Course

(Choice of One)

Lobster Ravioli

Homemade ravioli filled with lobster meat, sauteed with brandy pink sauce.

Entrée

(Choice of One)

Turkey

Traditional turkey, sweet potato, stuffing, cranberry sauce.

Ribeye Steak

Bone-in, dry-aged in-house.

NY Strip Steak

Bone-in, dry-aged in-house.

Branzino

Grilled whole Mediterranean bass.

Zupa Di Pesceе

Shrimp, scallop, calamari, octopus, fish of the day, white wine, shallots, plum tomato, fresh basil.

Side

(Choice of One)

Broccoli Sautéed
Creamed Spinach
Mashed Potatoes

Dessert

(Choice of One)

Pumpkin Pie
Blueberry Cheesecake
Blackout Cаке
  • Reserve
  • Parties
  • Jobs